Both Wittgenstein and Sellars oppose psychologism. In his argument against “private language”, Wittgenstein dismantles the notion of an “inner, private something”, while Sellars, in his critique of the “Myth of the Given”, replaces immediate perceptual givenness with observation reports that are normatively structured and situated within the logical space of reasons. Although distinct in formulation, their theories exhibit significant conceptual affinities. This paper briefly outlines the core arguments of both thinkers and offers a critical commentary on their approaches.
References
[1] Bonino, G., Tripodi, P. (2018) Sellars and Wittgenstein, Early and Late. Sellars and the History of Modern Philosophy, 216-232.
[2] Guidi, L. (2019) Emotions as embodied expressions: Wittgenstein on the inner life. HUMANA. MENTE Journal of Philosophical Studies, 12(36), 146-169.
[3] Ohtani, H. (2021) Reflective equilibrium from a Wittgensteinian perspective. Philosophia, 49(4), 1631-1649.
[4] Miller, A. (2019) Rule-following, meaning, and primitive normativity. Mind, 128(511), 735-760.
[5] O’Shea, J. (2021) Relocating the Myth of the Given in Lewis and Sellars. CI Lewis, 195-215.
[6] Tang, R. (2022) Exorcising the Myth of the Given: the idea of doxasticism. Synthese, 200(4), 305.
[7] Garrison, J. (2019) The myth that Dewey accepts “the Myth of the Given”. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society, 55(3), 304-325.
[8] O’Shea, J. R. (2019) How pragmatist was Sellars? Reflections on an analytic Pragmatism. Wilfrid Sellars and Twentieth-Century Philosophy, 110-129.
[9] Dalla Pozza, C., Garola, C., Negro, A., Sergio, D. (2020) A pragmatic logic for expressivism. Theoria, 86(3), 309-340.
[10] Dach, S. (2021) Sellars, we-intentions and ought-statements. Synthese, 198(5), 4415-4439.
Share and Cite
Huang, S. (2025) Critiquing the Myth of the Given and the Rejection of Private Language – A Discussion Confined to the Theories of Sellars and Wittgenstein. Journal of Social Development and History, 1(6), 118-126. https://doi.org/10.71052/jsdh/HNMY6678