When discussing the predicament of women in Dream of the Red Chamber, “patriarchal oppression” has become the default framework for almost all discussions. This concept is not entirely wrong, but as an analytical tool, it is overly general and fails to explain a core fact: Why are the predicaments of women in the Jia Clan so vastly different under the same patriarchal system? Some wield power, some are confined to the inner chambers; some maneuver strategically, some die in depression. Attributing this simply to “patriarchy” precisely obscures the intricate layers of power gaps and wrestling spaces within the system. This paper introduces “institutional dependency” as the analytical starting point to illustrate a fundamental predicament of women in the Jia Clan. No matter how outstanding their individual talents are, their power is never earned autonomously, but must be attached to a man through blood ties, marital bonds, or emotional connections – power is always “borrowed”, not “their own”. Nevertheless, despite the strict system, women are not passive recipients. This paper focuses more on how these women act within the cracks of the dependency structure: How does Lady Wang use “motherhood” as a resource to seize and consolidate power in silence? How does Jia Tanchun transcend gender boundaries to intervene in family governance as a “temporary manager”? And how Concubine Zhao employs “loss of composure” and even “madness” as a special strategy of resistance? The three paths together form a complex and contradictory picture – the system both imprisons them and provides them with limited yet genuine bargaining chips. The intention of this paper is not to defend the old system; on the contrary, only by proceeding from the real logic of women’s actions can the depth of the structural tragedy be truly touched. A cruel paradox runs through: The more adept they are at using these rules, the more unable they are to break free from the fate of being devoured by the rules.
References
[1] Fong, G. S., Wang, G. (2023) Rethinking authorship and agency: women and gender in late imperial China. Journal of Chinese Literature and Culture, 10 (1), 1-10.
[2] Skinner, K., Salifu, J., Adomako Ampofo, A. (2025) “Edited and approved by women for maximum benefit of all readers”: newsprint journalism, the International Women’s Year and the remaking of a gendered national public in 1970s Ghana. Gender & History, 37, 731-747.
[3] Lu, S. (2024) The early modern period, dream of the red chamber, and world literature. Journal of World Literature, 9(2), 207-225.
[4] Li, Z., Huang, D. J. (2022) Analysis of clans and employment in China from the aspect of gender. Growth and Change, 53(4), 1567-1591.
[5] Huang, F., Ye, H., Zhang, J. (2025) Off the books, away from the market: clan culture and female labor force participation. China Economic Review, 89, 102312.
[6] Zhou, Y. (2024) Portraying class and power: master-servant relationships in A Dream in Red Mansions and Downton Abbey. Journal of Humanities, Arts and Social Science, 8(2), 316-321.
[7] Chen, B. (2017) Material girls: silk and self-fashioning in Tang China (618-907). Fashion Theory, 21(1), 5-33.
[8] Xu, J., Ding, X., Eggers, T. (2024) Poverty risks of women in ancient china: How social institutions shaped the poverty risks faced by women during the ming-qing period. Journal of Family History, 49(3), 227-244.
[9] Wang, S. (2022) Comparison of independent female images in chinese and american literature: a case study of Jia Tanchun in A Dream of Red Mansions and Scarlett O’Hara in Gone with the Wind. British Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and History, 2(2), 20-24.
[10] Qian, X. (2022) Life dilemmas of the male characters in a dream of red mansions. Innovation Humanities and Social Sciences Research, 1(1), 114-121.
[11] Huntington, R. (2023) Recent companions and guides to the traditional chinese novel. Chinese Literature, Essays, Articles, Reviews, 45, 215-222.
[12] Hao, F., Zhang, S., Xiao, H. (2021) A return to innocence: guimi tourism and women empowerment. International Journal of Tourism Research, 23(6), 971-983.
Share and Cite
Miao, S. (2025) An Analysis of the Power Structure in Dream of the Red Chamber from a Feminine Perspective – From Institutional Dependency to Agency in the Interstices. Journal of Social Development and History, 1(5), 148-153.